Without further ado...
4 Reasons I Think Tom Renney Was Coaching Tonight's Game vs. San Jose Instead of John Tortorella...
1) The first clue I had that Mr. Renney was behind the bench and not Mr. Tortorella was that Steve Valiquette wasn't pulled after the 4th goal was given up. Mr. Tortorella would have put in Henrik Lundqvist at that point, regardless of whose fault the goal was. He would have switched goalies to wake his team up. This inkling that Mr. Renney was coaching tonight was only made stronger when the game became 5-2 and Valiquette stayed in net.
2) The 2nd clue was the Intermission Switch. Classic Tom Renney right there. Mr. Renney doesn't switch goalies mid-period. He waits until the 2nd intermission, then sends the new goalie out. He doesn't like to hurt anyone's feelings.
2) Michal Rozsival and Wade Redden were defensive partners for much of the game, especially at 4-2 and 5-2. Mr. Tortorella would never do that, he has too much sense. However, Mr. Renney still seems to be relying on players' salaries, not players' skills, to win the game.
3) The 4th line was on the ice in the 3rd period. While Mr. Tortorella "shortens the bench" when he wants to win the game. In previous seasons, Mr. Renney often would use Colton Orr, Blair Betts, and whoever else was on the 4th line to "shut down the opposition" while they added no offensive value whatsoever. Notice tonight's 4 shifts in the 3rd period for Donnie Brashear when they needed a goal.
4) Petr Prucha didn't play tonight for the Rangers. That's a staple of Mr. Renney's reign.
No, of course, I jest. There are 3 reasons I know Tom Renney didn't coach the Rangers tonight...
1) He works in Edmonton, and Edmonton won a 2-1 game. If that doesn't scream Tom Renney, I don't know what does.
2) Redden and Rozsival played a grand total of 0 seconds on the power play. If this was a Renney Game, they each would've had time at the point, passing up on shots, missing the net, and letting the puck bounce over their sticks and out of the zone.
3) Jed Ortmeyer scored tonight. He never scored in a Tom Renney game!
* * *
Redden and Rozsival were especially atrocious tonight. Any good that Redden did in those games against Toronto was washed away tonight. He wasn't physical (okay, he did land one check when he fell onto a Shark); he couldn't pass the puck correctly; he let people fly by him. To those who say I'm too harsh on him, were you watching this game?
When either of them are on the ice, I want the Garden fans to chant "AHL! AHL!"
* * *
That said, I did see two firsts at MSG tonight. One was my first Michael Del Zotto #4 jersey - the first of many, no doubt. (I saw my first Matt Gilroy #97 jersey Wednesday against the Kings).
The other first? The first time I ever saw a Wade Redden #6 jersey on a Ranger fan. Don't believe me? Look!
Wade Redden's cousin, or nephew, or some other family member, at Madison Square Garden. 10/19/09
I've been a bit inundated with texts and what not lately - please forgive me. My phone battery usually lasts about four days; it's died twice over the past 36 hours.
ReplyDeleteIf the Rangers were going to lay an egg in October, this was the best game to do so. It's a Western Conference opponent who the Rangers most likely won't be seeing in the playoffs, and they already proved they're pretty much for real. This, of course, is in direct contrast to the Islanders, who have proven they're for real when it comes to being awful. If they had beaten the Sharks, it could have gone down as the highlight of their 2009-10 season. Alas, it was not to be.
=( and lol at #4. So sad and so true.
ReplyDeleteThis game did not have the feel of Tortorella or good Rangers hockey though, you are spot on. And it was throughout the entire game. And they couldn't fake it this time like they were able to in Toronto.
Wow, Wade Redden's body double must be doing a crappy job to get seats that far from the glass.
ReplyDelete