Crossroads

Right now is an interesting time to be an Islanders fan. Half the fanbase wants the team to play as well as possible. The other half wants the Islanders to lose the rest of their games. Who's right? Who knows.

It's tempting to come out and say something like, "If you're rooting for the Islanders to tank the rest of the season, you're not a real fan." Because it's not true. We've seen this many times in the past - a season becomes a total loss, after which the Islanders suddenly start playing well and get everybody all excited about the following year. Remember the second half of the 1999-00 season, when the Islanders were better than .500 and played some pretty good hockey despite giving regular shifts to guys like Mark Lawrence and Mats Lindgren? After that season, the Islanders won the draft lottery, made the infamous Rick DiPietro deal, ended October 2000 in first place... and went on to finish dead last in the NHL. Similar late-season "flourishes" occurred in 1992, 1997, and 1998; only the '92 example yielded any sort of success the following season. So you'll forgive Islanders fans if they're not buying the hype this time around.

Let's face it - Islanders fans deserve something. Anyone who has supported this team, anyone who has bought a third jersey; hell, anyone who has so much as paid for a ticket this year deserves something. Islanders fans went into this year knowing it'd be rough, and they willingly went along. And all you have to do is look at the Islanders' DVD set to see how little they've had to cheer for lately. The past 20 years have brought about pretty much nothing. The 1993 team easily could have won the Stanley Cup, but lost out to Patrick Roy and the Canadiens. Nearly a decade of atrocious play followed, and when the Islanders lost to Toronto in that bitter seven-game series in 2002, many fans thought it was the start of something special. Turns out that the series itself was not just the only reward for years of mediocrity, it was the only significant two weeks of Islanders hockey to take place this century. I know you're supposed to pay a big price for winning four straight Cups, but the Islanders' faithful have had more than their fair share of heartache.

That's where all of this is coming from. It's not about tanking in the sense of wanting your team to lose. It's more about having gone through so much that it doesn't faze you anymore. To Islanders fans, a 30th place finish wouldn't mean anything except just one more bad year in a string of them. They've been the 8th seed before, and they've been anonymously awful before. Why not be awful when there's a reward for it?

On the other hand, it's hard not to be inspired by the Islanders' play of late. In fact, it's been nearly a month since they've laid a total egg. In that period of time, their only regulation losses have been a 1-0 loss to Pittsburgh, a tough 4-2 loss to the Rangers, and a well-played 2-1 loss to Boston. Those are three playoff teams, and two of those were road games. (Insert your own joke about how the Rangers game was really a road game.) Granted, the Islanders haven't exactly played the toughest schedule, but they've taken road games in New Jersey, Montreal and Chicago over that stretch and have developed a ton of confidence playing well against teams they should play well against. Today's lineup included one player who was waived earlier this season and eight players who have spent significant time in Bridgeport this year. And yeah, you might have seen this kind of thing in prior years, but this is pretty cool.

The difference between this Islanders team and the ones in the past is that this team has a plan. They have an organizational philosophy and stability at coach and general manager. They know what kind of team they want to build and they seem to have a pretty good grasp on how to build it. They also know which players don't fit and have gotten rid of these players. It's no coincidence that the Islanders are 8-3-2 since trading Chris Campoli and Mike Comrie to Ottawa; 4-2-1 since trading Bill Guerin to Pittsburgh. Not to denigrate these players, but certain players fit this system best and the Islanders deserve credit for weeding out the parts that don't fit. This isn't rebuilding with the likes of Eric Fichaud and Niklas Andersson - this is a team, and it's starting to show.

Of course, if you're of the mindset that the Islanders should intentionally lose every game for the rest of the season, that's your prerogative. You're certainly not incorrect, that's for sure. I, for one, believe in karma, and tanking sort of plays with the fates a little too much. Besides, you can't coach players to lose, and this experience will help them in the future. And there's always the chance that the Islanders could finish as high as 26th and still end up with the first overall pick. The moral of the story is, you can't worry so much about draft picks, because you can never control what will happen. What you can control, though, is the talent you have, and it looks like many of these players are starting to turn the corner. And in a season that has given Islanders fans very little to cheer about, I'll take it.